Search: Web        
powered by
The Dish with Jess Harter ~ Pursuing food and fun across the East Valley

Arizona vs. Pittsburgh: Battle of the bellies

January 27th, 2009, 8:38 pm · 4 Comments · posted by Jess Harter

The action won’t just be taking place on the field Sunday when the Arizona Cardinals meet the Pittsburgh Steelers in Super Bowl XLIII. In living rooms and bars across the Valley and western Pennsylvania, fans will be enjoying their respective signature foods and drinks. Here’s a decidedly biased look at how the two regions’ cuisines stack up:

FAVORITE CONDIMENT

Ketchup: Henry John Heinz founded the Anchor Pickle and Vinegar Works in 1869 and began selling ketchup four years later. Today, Pittsburgh-based H.J. Heinz Company sells more than $1 billion in ketchup annually (along with everything from pasta to fruit juice), allowing it to pay $57 million in 2001 for naming rights to the Steelers’ Heinz Field.

Salsa: Red or green, thick or thin, spicy or sweet — does any other condiment offer so much diversity and adaptability? Like ketchup, you can put it on hamburgers, hot dogs or fried potatoes. Unlike ketchup, it also goes great with chips, tacos, grilled chicken or fish, eggs and … well, just about any food.

Advantage: Arizona

FAVORITE WAY TO WRAP FOOD

Pierogi: Introduced to western Pennsylvania by Slavic immigrants, these half-circular dumplings of unleavened dough are stuffed with mashed potatoes, cheese, meat or vegetables. According to a friend from neighboring Ohio, pierogi are popular with Pittsburghers because they’re soft enough to be eaten by people with missing teeth.

Burrito: Popular on both sides of the U.S.-Mexico border, burritos are flour tortillas wrapped around a combination of fillings, typically meat, rice, beans, cheese, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and salsa. Entire restaurant chains — from locals (like Someburros) to nationals (like Chipotle) — have been launched by burritos.

Advantage: Arizona

FAVORITE SANDWICH TOPPING

French fries and cole slaw: Primanti Brothers, which started as a wood stand in the early 1930s, came up with the idea of putting fried potatoes and cole slaw on nearly every type of sandwich — saving people the daunting task of eating the side dishes separately — and became a Pittsburgh institution, now with 14 restaurants in the city.

Chili peppers: Man has been eating chiles for nearly 8,000 years. Here in the Valley, you can find them in everything from the habanero cheeseburger at Carlsbad Tavern to the chipotle barbecue sauce on the pulled pork sandwich at San Tan Brewing to the jalapeño jack cheese on the Southwestern club at Dilly’s Deli, just to name a few.

Advantage: Arizona

FAVORITE MEAT PREPARATION

Chipped ham: Isaly’s, a chain of dairies and restaurants, created this luncheon meat in 1933 by taking a loaf of chopped ham and “chipping” it against a meat slicer blade to make razor-thin slices, a process also known as “Pittsburgh style.” As with pierogi, one can only assume this is a benefit for the dentally challenged.

Barbecue beef: Mention barbecue in the South, and you’re usually referring to pork. In the West, however, you’re primarily talking about beef. One corporate  chef of a large barbecue chain — who’s spent a decade checking out barbecue all over the country — told me the pecan-smoked sliced beef brisket at Joe’s Real BBQ in Gilbert is the best he’s ever had.

Advantage: Arizona

FAVORITE HOMETOWN BEER

Iron City Beer: Pittsburgh’s Iron City Brewery Company began making one of America’s first lagers in 1861 and pioneered the use of aluminum cans, presumably so Steeler fans could crush them against their foreheads more easily. With a thin body and stale aftertaste, its flagship pilsner, Iron City, is a favorite of very old men.

Kiltlifter Ale: In just a dozen years, Tempe’s Four Peaks Brewing Company has established itself as an acclaimed brewer, and Kiltlifter, its flagship Scottish-style ale, has won medals at the Great American Beer Festival three times. With a slightly sweet, slightly smoky flavor, the amber ale is enjoyed by beer lovers of all ages.

Advantage: Arizona

FAVORITE SWEET TREAT

Klondike Bars: This longtime Pittsburgh favorite also was introduced at Isaly’s, the store that created chipped ham, in the 1920s. The chocolate-covered squares of ice cream didn’t go national until 1982 but now are available in more than 90 percent of U.S. supermarkets. They come in 13 flavors, many inspired by candy bars.

Fairytale Brownies: Started in 1992 by Phoenix childhood friends Eileen Spitalny and David Kravetz, this direct-mail gourmet brownie business ships more than 2.5 million brownies a year all over the world. They’re also available in 13 flavors — but all-natural, free of trans fats, hydrogenated oils, preservatives and artificial colors.

Advantage: Arizona

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks

4 Comments

  • roguemaster666 says:

    Jess Harter, your favoritism is most evident. As always, EVT cannot remain non-bias on any issue. Having lived in both locations, I can say that both offer great food choices, et al. I understand you wanting the Cards to win. Just remember, they are facing the #1 Defense. By the way, your wisecracks about Pittsburgher’s being “dentally challenged” could get you ending up the same way. But, as I said before, what else could be expected from anyone that works for the EVT? I must admit, with your “triple chin”, you would seem to have a great deal more food experience than myself…

  • Joe says:

    Okay, I agree with everything except the last one. How are you going to choose some brownie that no ones heard of over the Klondike bar that is an American classic? I mean I get the whole point of the thing is just some fun trash talk for the super bowl but lets get real.

  • Linda A. says:

    Do you suppose the Cardinals coach has compared teams? I hope we do have the team advantage in Florida or our red birds will be eating crow.

  • roguemaster666 says:

    By the way, the Head Coach of the Cards IS from the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Leave a Reply

ADVERTISEMENT